How one small state ignited a big argument about pizza supremacy
True pizza lovers get VERY defensive about what pizza style is best, and regionally it gets even more heated. New York swears it owns the slice game. Chicago comes in loud with deep dish. Detroit and St. Louis lovers put up a claim also, But then—quietly, confidently—Connecticut slides into the conversation like, “Actually… it’s us.”
And then, things get interesting.
Connecticut is usually not the first place most people think of when they think “pizza capital,” but the state does have a good argument. Connecticut, especially the city of New Haven, has built a cult following around its own style, called apizza (pronounced “ah-beetz”).
And before you roll your eyes thinking New York should carry the crown, hear this out: people don’t just like New Haven pizza. They make pilgrimages for it because the style native to Connecticut is legendary in the world of pizza. Places like Sally’s Apizza, Modern Apizza, and Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana are world renowed.
What Makes New Haven Style Different?
First off, the crust. It’s thin, but not floppy like New York. When made correctly it’s got a perfect balance—crispy, chewy, and just a little charred from the coal-fired ovens they’re cooked in. Some come out looking slightly burnt, but that’s intentional. The char? That’s flavor.
Then there’s the sauce, which is typically tangier and less sweet than the tomato sauce used on most other styles of pizza.
And cheese? Here’s where things get weird (be careful what you order!). In New Haven, ordering a “plain” pizza often means you’ll get it without mozzarella, since locals consider mozzarella to be a topping.Sometimes it’s just a light sprinkle of Romano—or none at all. The focus is on the dough and sauce.
In it’s defense, New Haven style pizza is good, but Connecticut went so far as to proudly proclaim they are best by putting it on a license plate. Yes, Connecticut released specialty plates that say “The Pizza State.” Not “one of the best,” not “pretty good at pizza.” Connecticut just outright claimed the crown like the debate has already been settled. That’s basically picking a fight with the rest of the Northeast.
New York and New Jersey are not exactly staying quiet about Connecticut’s claim. New York’s response is pretty straightforward: it sees itself as the global face of pizza. The classic New York slice is everywhere, instantly recognizable, and deeply tied to the city’s identity. From their perspective, calling Connecticut the pizza capital feels almost absurd. New Jersey, meanwhile, takes a slightly different approach. It argues that it has some of the best pizzerias in the country, saying they don’t need to advertise on license plates or highway signs to prove it.
In the end, there may never be a universally agreed upon pizza capital of America, and maybe that’s okay. Pizza thrives on regional identity, and each state brings something different to the table. Still, Connecticut’s claim has turned it from an underdog into a serious contender.
Putting it on a license plate might seem a little bold, but it has definitely succeeded in sparking the pizza conversation. And really, the only way to decide where you stand in the debate is to do the research yourself – one slice at a time.
~ Marty the Pizza Guy ~
Let me know what you think!